The Modding Tree games Tier Lists

General
#1

Post your tier list of TMT games you’ve played so far.
One list per user, to not make this too cluttered, edit if you must. And please remember these things (placements and tiers) are based on opinion. After all, the main drive in developing, playing, and analyzing is fun and passion, plus all these games are released for free and even those in the lower tiers are functional and you may still find them enjoyable.
I also link to my reviews hosted on TV Tropes if you want more detailed thoughts (I’m unlikely to make reviews for all of them, but they’re there).
Open the sections for the specific tiers to see them! (Some of them may be large)

A Tier (Awesome)
  • Advent Incremental
  • The Communitree (Review)
  • The Game Dev Tree (Review)
  • The Incremental God Tree (Review)
  • Lit+ (original is B tier)
  • The Milestone Tree
  • The Multitree (Review)
  • Primordia (Review)
  • Universal Reconstruction
B Tier (Good)
  • Antreematter Dimensions
  • The Challenge Tree
  • Collection of Everything
  • The Dynas Tree
  • The Factoree (Review)
  • Falling Mountain’s AlterPrestige
  • The Gaokao Tree
  • The Incremental Dev Tree
  • The Incrementali Tree
  • The Incrementreeverse
  • The Leveling Tree
  • Plague Tree (Review)
  • The Prestige Rectangle
  • Prestige Tree (Classic and Rewritten)
  • Prestige Tree Dimensions (Review)
  • The Prestreestuck
  • The Tree of Life (Review)
  • The Tree of Nerfs 2
  • The Upgrading Tree
C Tier (Decent)
  • Despacit Tree Delta (Review)
  • The Formula
  • The Energy Tree
  • The h0nde Tree (Review)
  • The Null Tree
  • The Prestige Chain Classic
  • Prestige Tree Condensed
  • A Prestige Tree Mod About Merging
  • Prestige Universe
  • The Side Project
  • The Space Tree
  • The User Tree (1 and 2)
  • The Word: TREE
  • The Prestige Tree: Alternate (only DespATPT, original is D tier, not made in TMT or Profectus but still)
D Tier (Barely adequate)
  • The Atomic Tree
  • The Compact Tree
  • The GFRIEND Tree (Review)
  • The Fuel Tree
  • Infinite Softcaps
  • The Millennium Tree
  • The Stardust Tree (Review)
  • Tree Inc.
  • The Tree of Death
E Tier (Poor)
  • The 64 Layers Tree
  • The Alphabet Tree
  • The Burning Tree (Review)
  • The Pg Tree
  • The Prestige Forest
  • Too Many Softcaps
X Tier (Quality unclassifiable, clearly joke/satire/April Fools games or made by me)
  • The Blob War
  • A Fun And Interactive Idle Game
  • The RNG Tree (Review)
  • The Tree of Nerfs
  • The Ascension Tree (not made in TMT or Profectus but still) (Review)

Things which can earn your game a higher spot on a tier list (at least mine):

  • A good amount of content (I like to leave it satisfied with the amount of stuff it provided)
  • Good balancing (should not rely on timewalls or mashing the reset button)
  • A unique and fleshed-out core mechanic
  • An interesting theme
  • Some cool side additions that add charm (a lore, icons)
  • No glitches or oversights that hamper enjoyment
  • An overall feeling of polish
3 Likes
#2

A Tier (very good)

  • Prestige Tree Rewritten
  • Milestone Tree
  • Alterprestige
  • Prestige Tree Alternate
  • Game Dev Tree
  • APTMAM

B Tier (good)

  • Tuba’s Tree (my own game but still I think I can rank it)
  • Communitree (take this with a side of salt because I haven’t played the whole thing)
  • Prestige Tree Dimensions
  • Multitree (take this with a side of salt because I haven’t played the whole thing)

C Tier (alright)

  • Vorona
  • Incrementreeverse
  • Tree of Life (take this with a side of salt because I haven’t played the whole thing)
2 Likes
#3

These aren’t every mod that I have played so there’s probably some shorter or older mods that I forgot about.

My Faves:

  • The Tree of Life
  • The Multitree
  • The Prestige Tree Classic
  • The Game Dev Tree
  • The Dynas Tree (really wish the exploration part didn’t happen so late though)
  • The Incremtreeverse (before the end parts)

Solid Mods:

  • The Plague Tree
  • Falling Mountain’s Alterprestige
  • Prestige Tree Rewritten (my first playthrough was torturous - affects my rankings a bit)
  • The Gaokao Tree
  • The Prestreestuck
  • The Factoree
  • The Prestige Chain Classic
  • The Leveling Tree
  • The Milestone Tree
  • The Formula

Kinda Mid, To Be Honest:

  • Prestige Chain Reincarnated (the gameplay loop never changes as of writing this.)
  • Communitree (Hottest take of the thread, it’s just a waiting sim without anything to look at while you wait)
  • The Function of Time (I stopped exactly when the game threw me a repeat of the first layer but long and arduous)
  • APTMAM (The start IS interesting but a lot of the prestige layers just don’t work)
2 Likes
#4

Not all of them, I feel like I’ve played all the good ones
:+1::
The plague tree (really well made, as far as I can see)
The prestreestuck (homestuck brainrot go brrr)
The multitree (really really good, would recommend)
The milestone tree (really unique but not bad? Yes please)
Tree quest (short but sweet)
The one with bamboo and mushrooms (can’t remember name, really fun)
Antreematter (fun, not as timewally as antimatter dimensions
Alterprestige (really well made)
TPTR (played it before classic, like it more)
TPTC (got to gears, stopped)
:-1::
The tree of life (either timewalls or grinding all the time? No thank you)
Tree of life (I just hold a lot of hate for the tree of life)
Tree of life
Just tree of life I think
A bunch of smaller mods.

2 Likes
#5

The Prestreestuck Z minus 1.7977e308

1 Like
#6

A tier
The mod i made and am currently working on (Incremental Dev Tree and Incremental God Tree)
Communitree
Prestreestuck
Game Dev Tree (First mod i’ve ever played)
PT:R and PT:C

B Tier
Plague Tree
Antreematter
Challenge Tree
Arctree
Advent Incremental

C Tier
Milestone Tree
Prestige Chain
Tree of death
alterprestige

ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ tier
Tree of life (a horrible abomination of a mod and is 33% of #mod-updates on the discord)

1 Like
#7

same as randomtuba

1 Like